Skip to content

GMC Sierra 1500 vs Chevrolet Silverado 1500: which has more problems

GMC Sierra 1500 and Chevrolet Silverado 1500 side by side: owner complaints by component, problem years, service bulletins and engines. Same data as on each model page.

More complaints often just means more cars sold, so compare the pattern of problems and the years, not only the total.

At a glance

GMC Sierra 1500

  • Model years in data: 1994–2027
  • Owner complaints: 9,082 (after a crash 261, fires 0)
  • Complaints per model year (average): 267
  • Service bulletins: 3,316
  • Worst years: 2014 (744), 2015 (721), 2019 (662)

Chevrolet Silverado 1500

  • Model years in data: 1994–2027
  • Owner complaints: 18,178 (after a crash 758, fires 0)
  • Complaints per model year (average): 535
  • Service bulletins: 3,396
  • Worst years: 2014 (1,438), 2015 (1,111), 2019 (1,104)

Components: owner complaints

Component GMC Sierra 1500 Chevrolet Silverado 1500
Service brakes 1,714 19% 4,535 25%
Engine 2,135 24% 2,700 15%
Powertrain 1,369 15% 2,535 14%
Electrical system 1,223 13% 2,714 15%
Air bags 952 10% 2,411 13%
Steering 617 7% 1,529 8%
Structure 607 7% 933 5%
Fuel/propulsion system 301 3% 481 3%
Engine and cooling 267 3% 478 3%
Exterior lighting 339 4% 285 2%
Suspension 219 2% 522 3%
Visibility 204 2% 477 3%

Which is more reliable: GMC Sierra 1500 or Chevrolet Silverado 1500?

This data alone can't settle it: complaint counts depend on sales. Compare which components draw the most complaints (service brakes, engine, powertrain) and which years are worst, then check the specific car by VIN and photos.

Check a specific car by VIN and photos

Other comparisons