Skip to content

Toyota Highlander vs Honda Pilot: which has more problems

Toyota Highlander and Honda Pilot side by side: owner complaints by component, problem years, service bulletins and engines. Same data as on each model page.

More complaints often just means more cars sold, so compare the pattern of problems and the years, not only the total.

At a glance

Toyota Highlander

  • Model years in data: 1997–2026
  • Owner complaints: 5,810 (after a crash 477, fires 0)
  • Complaints per model year (average): 208
  • Service bulletins: 505
  • Worst years: 2021 (538), 2019 (510), 2008 (406)

Honda Pilot

  • Model years in data: 2003–2026
  • Owner complaints: 9,442 (after a crash 348, fires 0)
  • Complaints per model year (average): 393
  • Service bulletins: 485
  • Worst years: 2016 (1,728), 2017 (942), 2019 (929)

Components: owner complaints

Component Toyota Highlander Honda Pilot
Engine 543 9% 2,375 25%
Electrical system 636 11% 2,070 22%
Powertrain 1,067 18% 1,333 14%
Service brakes 757 13% 646 7%
Air bags 359 6% 738 8%
Structure 446 8% 420 4%
Vehicle speed control 445 8% 377 4%
Fuel/propulsion system 271 5% 639 7%
Steering 365 6% 342 4%
Visibility 530 9% 0 0%
Engine and cooling 182 3% 249 3%
Forward collision avoidance 0 0% 523 6%

Which is more reliable: Toyota Highlander or Honda Pilot?

This data alone can't settle it: complaint counts depend on sales. Compare which components draw the most complaints (engine, electrical system, powertrain) and which years are worst, then check the specific car by VIN and photos.

Check a specific car by VIN and photos

Other comparisons